Bad Faith Insurance

BAD FAITH

In general liability insurance, "bad faith" signifies the insurer's failure to uphold its obligation to the insured. Every insurance agreement inherently includes an implicit commitment of "good faith and fair dealing," which sets a standard mandating both parties to refrain from actions that could harm the other party's entitlement to the benefits outlined in the agreement.

For an insurer, conducting business in "good faith" entails processing claims promptly, honestly, and comprehensively. Any breach of this duty by the insurer constitutes an act of "bad faith."

BAD FAITH INSURANCE LAWSUIT

A lawsuit filed in bad faith occurs when an insured individual takes legal action against their insurance provider for acting dishonestly. This typically involves the insurer not meeting their obligations outlined in the insurance policy or purposefully denying or prolonging a claim without a valid justification.

The notion of bad faith within insurance law encompasses various wrongful behaviors by insurers, including:

• Unreasonably delaying the processing of a claim.
• Rejecting a claim without a legitimate rationale.
• Failing to conduct a thorough investigation into a claim.
• Neglecting to provide legal defense to the policyholder when mandated by the policy.
• Misrepresenting the terms or scope of coverage in the policy.
• Offering a settlement amount significantly lower than the actual value of the claim.

HOW TO TELL IF AN INSURANCE COMPANY ACTED IN BAD FAITH

Identifying whether an insurer has engaged in bad faith practices can be complex, often requiring an understanding of the nuances within your policy and the legality of insurance procedures. Here are indicators that suggest an insurance company might be acting in bad faith:

1. Unexplained denial of a claim: If your claim is rejected without a clear rationale, it could signal bad faith on the part of the insurer.
2. Excessive delays: If the insurer prolongs the investigation or resolution of your claim unreasonably, it may indicate bad faith.
3. Inadequate settlement offers: If the insurer proposes a settlement significantly below the reasonable value of your claim, it could be acting in bad faith.
4. Lack of communication: If the insurer fails to respond to your inquiries or provide updates on your claim status, it might be suggestive of bad faith.
5. Policy misrepresentation: If the insurer distorts the policy language unreasonably or misrepresents coverage, it may be engaging in bad faith.

The concept of the "implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing" is fundamental to contracts, including insurance agreements. It's an implicit obligation requiring all parties to deal with each other honestly, fairly, and in good faith, ensuring that none obstructs the other from receiving the contract's benefits.

In the realm of insurance, a breach of this covenant may occur if the insurer fails to fulfill its contractual duties in the following ways:

1. Inadequate claim investigation: A failure to conduct a thorough and impartial investigation of a claim could constitute a breach.
2. Unjustified claim denial: Denying a claim without a valid reason or based on unreasonable policy interpretation may breach the covenant.
3. Delayed payments: Unnecessary delays in claim processing or payment without justification can be considered breaches.
4. Unfair settlement practices: Offering a settlement significantly below the claim's value may breach the covenant.
5. Failure to defend: In liability insurance, refusing to defend a policyholder in court as obligated by the policy could be a breach.
6. Policy misrepresentation: Misrepresenting policy terms to the policyholder's detriment may also be a breach.

It's important to note that not all claim denials or disputes with an insurer necessarily indicate bad faith. Genuine disagreements about policy interpretation or claim facts can occur. Consulting a lawyer is advisable if you suspect bad faith on the part of your insurer..

For assistance in navigating such matters, consider reaching out to Prime Law Firm.

EXAMPLE OF FAILING TO CONDUCT A REASONABLE INVESTIGATION

Consider a scenario where a homeowner files a claim for water damage on their property. If the insurance company refuses the claim without dispatching an adjuster to assess the damage, or if the adjuster conducts a superficial inspection, overlooking crucial details, this could be interpreted as a failure to conduct a thorough investigation.

WHAT TO DO IF AN INSURANCE COMPANY ACTED IN BAD FAITH

If you suspect your insurance company has behaved in bad faith, you can pursue various legal avenues:

1. Attempt negotiation: You can seek resolution by engaging with the company directly, potentially escalating the matter to a higher-ranking representative or utilizing the services of a company ombudsman.
2. Explore mediation or arbitration: If direct negotiation proves ineffective, you might opt for mediation or arbitration, which typically offer less formal and less costly alternatives to litigation.
3. Consider litigation: Should the insurer persist in its bad faith actions, you have the option to file a bad faith lawsuit. It's advisable to enlist the assistance of an attorney specializing in insurance law for this process.

STEPS TO TAKE IN DEALING WITH AN INSURANCE COMPANY WHO ACTED IN BAD FAITH

1. Know your policy inside out: Familiarize yourself with the terms, coverage, limitations, and exclusions outlined in your insurance policy.
2. Keep thorough documentation: Maintain records of all communications, claims, and interactions with your insurer. These records can serve as crucial evidence in case of disputes.
3. Seek professional assistance: If you encounter difficulties with your insurer, consider hiring a public adjuster or an attorney specializing in insurance law. They can advocate on your behalf, negotiate with the insurer, and safeguard your rights.
4. File a complaint: If your insurer mishandles your claim, you have the option to lodge a complaint with your state's insurance department. They can investigate your complaint and potentially aid in resolving the issue.
5. Explore legal recourse cautiously: If the insurer persists in acting in bad faith, you may contemplate initiating legal action against them. However, this step should be a last resort, pursued only after exhausting other avenues of resolution.

For assistance in navigating such matters, consider reaching out to Prime Law Firm.

KINDS OF DAMAGES RECOVERED IN A BAD FAITH CLAIM

In a bad faith claim, you may potentially recover more than just the initial value of your insurance claim. Possible recoverable damages include:

1. Compensatory damages: These encompass the original claim amount that should have been paid, along with any additional expenses incurred due to the insurer's bad faith actions. These damages are applicable in worker's compensation claims and other personal injury cases.
2. Consequential damages: These represent further losses directly resulting from the insurer's bad faith, such as legal fees.
3. Punitive damages: In cases of particularly egregious conduct by the insurer, the court may grant punitive damages, aiming to punish the insurer and deter similar behavior in the future. Emotional distress damages: Certain jurisdictions permit recovery for emotional distress caused by the insurer's bad faith actions.

SHOULD I HIRE A LAWYER?

If you suspect that your insurance provider has engaged in bad faith practices, seeking guidance from a lawyer is strongly advised. An attorney specializing in insurance law can offer essential counsel, clarify your entitlements, and advocate on your behalf during negotiations or legal proceedings.

Prime Law Firm offers a convenient platform for connecting with qualified attorneys. We can assist you in locating a lawyer experienced in insurance law and capable of addressing your bad faith claim effectively.

Share your case details with Prime Law Firm today to get started.

Call our office today at 212-994-7777 or complete the convenient online contact form to set up a consultation.

PRIME LAW FIRM SERVES CLIENTS IN NEW YORK & FLORIDA